May. 16th, 2024

pangolin20: A picture of a white crow in a tree (Corneille Blanche)
[personal profile] pangolin20

minionnumber2 wrote in antishurtugal, 2018-08-22 01:50:00

Brisingr Spork Chapter 53: Greaves and Bracers

Oops, almost forgot it was my turn again.

This entire chapter is about two pages long and continues the trend of offering no insight into anything or really offering anything at all. Most of it is dedicated to trying to make putting on armor an intimate affair followed up by a cliche pre-war conversation. I wouldn’t hold it against anyone to just skip over this, because this is a chapter that should have been cut. It doesn’t advance the plot or any subplots and it doesn’t offer any character or world development.

I’m going to try and limit this to what we know about in-universe because I don’t think my ~5 hours of research on historic armor is going to be much better than Christopher "Meticulous Research" Paolini in the credibility department. A quick shoutout to Hergrim and ggSauron for resources and advice though!

Read more... )
pangolin20: A picture of a white crow in a tree (Corneille Blanche)
[personal profile] pangolin20

theepistler wrote in antishurtugal, 2018-08-23 16:51:00

MOOD: hungry

Brisingr Spork: Chapter 54 - Leave-Taking

I wish these chapter titles were numbered. It’s probably the reason why my last spork was mis-numbered. Either way we’re into the home stretch now! Friggin’ finally.

Read more... )
pangolin20: A picture of a white crow in a tree (Corneille Blanche)
[personal profile] pangolin20

Pixen wrote in antishurtugal, 2018-08-25 23:31:00

Brisingr Spork: Chapter 55?: Flight

I'm baaaaaaack! My sporking style has possibly chaaaaanged! Hopefully for the better... My deliberate focus from here on in is to challenge myself not just to recap the chapter's events and snark about it (although snarking is admittedly a lot of fun) but to properly highlight what doesn't work and why, regarding plot, character motivations and prose. That's the plan, anyhow.

Read more... )
pangolin20: A picture of a white crow in a tree (Corneille Blanche)
[personal profile] pangolin20


snarkbotanya posting in antishurtugal_reborn, 2018-10-20 21:12

Brisingr Spork Part 56 - Brisingr!

ANVILS! DUCK!



[Caption: Gif of an anvil falling into a room and two people just ducking away.]


*dusts off* Well, isn’t that a fun way to start today’s sporking… seriously, Paolini, stop with these title drops in your chapter titles. It’s really obnoxious.


There's just so much FAILURE here! )

Next up on the Spork Train is Gharial, with “Shadow of Doom”. We’re almost there, folks!



Read more... )
pangolin20: A picture of a white crow in a tree (Corneille Blanche)
[personal profile] pangolin20


gharial posting in antishurtugal_reborn, 2018-10-21 19:46

Brisinger Spork: Part 57: Shadows of Doom

Lucky me. I get to spork both the most important chapter in the novel (the introduction of the Eldunari plot point) and the climax. Let’s delve right in (title sucks, but I'm not going to harp on that point).

The story opens with Eragon acting like a massive dick to some elves. And that’s not our antishirt bias, Arya even calls him out on it, but Eragon doesn’t have time to justify himself or argue because suddenly we’re switching to Glaedr’s pov as he flies of Gil’Ead. There doesn’t seem to be any express reason Glaedr is sharing his pov with Eragon. He makes no direct reference to Eragon in his mind, but he must be doing it consciously because Arya is just as close to his Eldunari and she’s not experiencing these flashes. It’s not like Eragon has any intrinsic link to Glaedr either like he does Saphira, he’s just the guy that happens to have Glaedr’s Eldunari nearby.
And because we’re once again looking through the eyes of a dragon, we of course get the tilde~dragon~language. We’ve complained about this at length before. It just doesn’t work stylishly, consistently or even linguistically. All it serves to do is make the dragons look less intelligent. There will be so many examples of it not working in this chapter, I won’t even bother naming them. Just assume every Glaedr scene comes with cringe.

Read more... )And that’s it for the climax of the book. I suppose it could have been worse. The stuff with Galbatorix is decent, the shade stuff was completely unnecessary, though I guess it didn’t blatantly contradict anything that had been previously established…which is a win as far as the series goes sometimes. I guess its good the book had some sort of climax rather than just ending abruptly. Only the last wrap up chapter left, I believe Torylltales has it written already, which means we can finally finish this spork and move on to Eragon. Ah the good old days when it seemed like Paolini gave a crap.

Read more... )
pangolin20: A picture of a white crow in a tree (Corneille Blanche)
[personal profile] pangolin20


torylltales posting in antishurtugal_reborn, 2018-10-23 07:17

Brisingr Spork Part The Last, At Last: Sunrise

FINAL CHAPTER: Sunrise

 

Read more... )
Page generated Jun. 25th, 2025 09:20 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios